CDC-INFO
(Center for Disease Control) advises the MRL standard for styrene set by ATSDR
(Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry) for kids' safety and health,
which is 260 micrograms per cubic meter, translating to about 60ppb.
Air testing results direct from the County reveal levels
which are multiples of this standard, reaching as high as 333ppb - 500 ppb (half
a ppm) according to Dirk Jensen from San Mateo County Environmental Health: jump
to Inspection data direct from the County
It
is important to note that, just because you can't smell it, it doesn't mean that
it's not there - what does it mean if you
are smelling the styrene odor? According to EPA / TTN, the odor threshold (the
lowest concentration point at which you can smell it) for styrene is 0.32 parts
per million (ppm), 320 ppb - that is over 5 times greater than the 60 ppb standard
for kids (source EPA/TTN).
"Its
odor is sweet at very low concentrations, but becomes sharp and disagreeable at
higher concentrations" (source dhs).
click
Factory Scorecard for more info on the chemical
emissions from Peterson Products, the 2002 3rd dirtiest facility for polluting
the community in San Mateo County
Acute
Effects: * Acute exposure to styrene
in humans results in respiratory effects, such as mucous membrane irritation,
eye irritation, and gastrointestinal effects.
Chronic
Effects (Noncancer): * Chronic
exposure to styrene in humans results in effects on the CNS (Central Nervous
System), with symptoms such as headache, fatigue, weakness, depression,
CNS dysfunction (reaction time, memory, visuomotor speed and accuracy, intellectual
function), and hearing loss, peripheral neuropathy (a condition of the nervous
system that usually begins in the hands and/or feet with symptoms of numbness,
tingling, burning and/or weakness), minor effects on some kidney enzyme functions
and on the blood. * Animal studies have reported effects on the CNS, liver,
kidney, and eye and nasal irritation from inhalation exposure to styrene.
* Liver, blood, kidney, and stomach effects have been observed in animals following
chronic oral exposure.
Reproductive/Developmental
Effects: * Increased frequency
of spontaneous abortions and a decreased frequency of births were reported in
a study on the reproductive effects of styrene in humans. * Lung tumors have
been observed in the offspring of orally exposed mice.
Cancer
Risk: * Several epidemiologic
studies suggest that there may be an association between styrene exposure and
an increased risk of leukemia and lymphoma. * IARC has classified styrene
as a Group 2B, possibly carcinogenic to humans. * Styrene oxide, a product of styrene
metabolism in the body, is an established mutagen and carcinogen and is believed
to be the reason for the toxicity of styrene.Styrene
oxide has been detected in workers exposed to styrene. IARC has classified this
metabolite as a Group 2A, probable human carcinogen.
Styrene:
EPA Regulated Hazardous Waste, listed
as toxic chemical "EPA has determined that emissions of these chemicals
present a threat to human health" "It
is readily absorbed through all routes of exposure and tends to store in fatty
tissues. Acute exposure causes eye and mucous membrane irritation, dizziness,
and even death
due to respiratory system paralysis." source:
EPA
Potential for Accumulation: Styrene
is readily absorbed following inhalation exposure and ingestion, and is widely
distributed throughout the body. A small amount is absorbed through the skin.
The highest concentration of styrene is found in fat tissue. Styrene is rapidly
metabolized to styrene oxide...Absorbed styrene is cleared from the body within
4 days. source: CCOHS
"DANGER!
FLAMMABLE LIQUID AND VAPOR. HARMFUL IF SWALLOWED, INHALED OR ABSORBED THROUGH
SKIN. CAUSES IRRITATION TO SKIN, EYES AND RESPIRATORY TRACT. AFFECTS CENTRAL NERVOUS
SYSTEM, LIVER AND REPRODUCTIVE SYSTEM." Read more at MSDS
Kids
Are at Greater Risk
Children especially are more vulnerable to exposures
than adults in communities faced with contamination of their air, water, soil,
or food for the following factors: 1) Children weigh less than adults, resulting
in higher doses of chemical exposure relative to body weight 2) The developing
bodily systems of children can suffer permanent damage if toxic exposures occur
during critical growth stages 3) Children have a breathing zone lower to the
ground 4) Children consume three times as
much air per pound of body weight as an adult, drink three times as much water
and eat three times as much food and thus are more susceptible to the effects
of toxic chemicals sources: Agency
for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR) , CDC-INFO
, VPIRG
Breathing
Rates: Newborns: Average 44 breaths
per minute Infants: 20-40 breaths per minute Preschool children: 20-30
breaths per minute Older children: 16-25 breaths per minute Adults: 12
to 20 breaths per minute source: Wikipedia
"Exercise
makes us more vulnerable to health damage from these pollutants. We breathe
more air during exercise or strenuous work. We draw air more deeply into the lungs.
And when we exercise heavily, we breathe mostly through the mouth, bypassing the
body's first line of defense against pollution, the nose."
"Oxygen
is necessary for our muscles to function. In fact, the purpose of exercise training
is to improve the body's ability to deliver oxygen. As a result, when we exercise,
we may increase our intake of air by as much as ten times our level at rest."
"An
endurance athlete can process as much as twenty times the normal intake.
Mouth breathing during exercise bypasses the nasal passages, the body's natural
air filter. These facts mean that when we exercise in polluted air, we increase
our contact with the pollutants, and increase our vulnerability to health damage.
The
interaction between air pollution and exercise is so strong that health scientists
typically use exercising volunteers in their research."
Recommendations
include: Do make sure teachers, coaches and recreation officials know about
air pollution and act accordingly. Most
important, do be aware of the quality of the air you breathe! Don't take
air pollution lightly, it can hurt all of us!
Is
there a medical test to show whether I've been exposed to styrene?
Styrene
and its breakdown products can be measured in your blood, urine, and body tissues.
Styrene leaves your body quickly. If you are tested within one day, the actual
amount of exposure can be estimated. However, it is difficult to predict if the
exposure will affect your health.
The
test for styrene and its breakdown products require special equipment and are
not usually available at your doctor's office, but may be ordered by the doctor.
Your doctor can take samples and send them to a testing laboratory. source:
CDC-INFO
If
you are concerned about being exposed to harmful levels of styrene, CDC-INFO
advises you contact your state health department and your regional EPA office:
click here for contacts
Sources
of Exposure
The
major way you can be exposed to styrene is by breathing air containing it.
Styrene is found in city air and indoor air. Styrene is released into the air
from industries that make and use styrene. It is also released from automobile
exhaust and cigarette smoke. Styrene can enter your body through your lungs if
you breathe contaminated air or through your stomach and intestines if you eat
or drink contaminated food or water. Styrene can also
pass through the skin into your body. source: CDC-INFO
Children
can inhale styrene from secondhand cigarette smoke. First on the list for "How
to minimize exposure to styrene" by Children's
Health Environmental Coalition (CHEC) is: "Reduce your children's exposure
to secondhand cigarette smoke". You probably wouldn't let your children be
around cigarette smoke with the "second-hand smoke kills" campaign (see
Related: Belmont's ban on smoking) - but it
actually contains less styrene than chemical emissions from a fiberglass factory
such as Peterson Products.
Most
airborne styrene exposure comes from industrial activities and motor vehicle exhaust,
with typical ambient concentrations reaching around 1 part per billion (ppb).
For smokers, the dominant source of inhaled styrene can be cigarettes, which can
increase average exposures for these individuals to 6 ppb. The
panel estimated that under a pessimistic set of conditions, individuals living
near a large styrene manufacturing facility could be exposed to lifetime average
ambient concentrations exceeding 200 ppb source:
Harvard
Center for Risk Analysis
Ok...so
let's talk numbers... CDC-INFO
(Center for Disease Control) advises the MRL standard for styrene set by ATSDR
(Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry) for kids' safety and health,
which is 260 micrograms per cubic meter, translating to about 60ppb.
Air testing results direct from the County reveal levels
which are multiples of this standard, reaching as high as 333ppb - 500 ppb (half
a ppm) according to Dirk Jensen from San Mateo County Environmental Health: "concentrations
I got were ranging from about a few ppb to maybe...around 150...I might
have gotten a couple hits up around a couple hundred ppb...Still nothing
that was exceeding ...an exposure limit for an 8-hour work day. ...I was getting
about a third to a half of... a ppm" (7/24/07)....more below:
Currently
Available Data from Environmental Health Inspections Summer
2007
Naomi
Bernardo from Bay Area Air Quality Management
District (BAAQMD) made inspections on Peterson Products based on this issue
starting June 21st, but would not take any air measurements, just make suggestions
to the factory on how to reduce chemical emissions coming from the factory.
San
Mateo County Environmental Health Department was then contacted. Tuesday
July 10, 2007: Dirk Jensen met with managers Erica Meitz and Margaret
Morrison at San Mateo Gymnastics, "They both stated that odor problem has
decreased considerably over the years however some odors still"*.
Dirk "believe[s] this is primarily a BAAQMD matter but [he] will investigate
further due to public health concern", left message for Naomi Bernardo. **view
Peterson Products chemical emissions reported from 1988-2005 Thursday
July 12, 2007: Dirk Jensen received notice that the odor problem
is still significant. Tuesday July 17, 2007: Dirk Jensen
notes he "conducted some monitoring at approx. 3pm in parking lot adjacent
to Peterson Products and San Mateo Gymnastics. Some readings in ppb range well
below exposure limit for chemicals associated with Peterson Products"**.
He "met with Bob Scheer, plant manager for Peterson Products and discussed
complaint. Naomi Bernardo from BAAQMD recently inspected business and made a number
of recommendations now being implemented at Peterson Products". No actual
measurements are noted. **The exposure
limit Dirk is referring to is OSHA's 100 ppm styrene limit for workers in a 8-hour
work day, 40-hour work week; styrene is rated "C", so at no time is
the limit supposed to exceed this amount. source: OSHAWould you use this limit
for your kids? CDC-INFO and
ATSDR advise otherwise:
~60 ppb!! -->see MRL info below Wednesday
July 18, 2007: Dirk "returned with monitoring equipment and
conducted monitoring in parking area and near gym...observed variable monitor
results ranging from 5-60 ppb." From
Dirk, 7/18/07: Peterson Products is "in compliance
with Air Quality...and with our agency for the most part". There are
"definitely some fairly high levels inside Peterson Products". "During
normal business hours...in theory the peak hours, work hours". "I did
talk to Erica and I did suggest that if the odors do get strong...they consider...putting
some fans there by the roll-up door...and I can't really...direct them...as far
as how to run a business...but I did make that suggestion again and she sort of
acknowledged that, but we'll see what happens". From Dirk, Tuesday
July 24, 2007: "I didn't get out there until right about 9:00
this morning, so they were still in production mode over at Peterson Products,
I'm fairly certain...the odors were comprable to what I observed last week, maybe
a little bit stronger...The readings I got...were strongest down towards Elmer,
along that alleyway...Karen Road...in that area, the parking area...on the backside
of the building...for the gym. By the roll-up door I didn't get anything that
significant, so the odors weren't that strong there,..they were a little higher,
... you know in concentrations I got were ranging
from about a few ppb to maybe...around 150...I might have gotten a couple hits
up around a couple hundred ppb which is...about maybe 3 or 4
times what I observed last week on my monitor. Still nothing that was exceeding
...an exposure limit for an 8-hour work day. ...I was getting about
a third to a half of... a ppm,...so...probably I guess...more
of a nuisance odor that anything else...unfortunately the levels are going to
vary...depending on the wind current...the type of work they're doing that day...I'm
not getting anything that I would consider a significant health hazard, it might
be a minor health hazard...I'll try to get
out 2 or 3 more times just to try to get...some data over a period of time....you
want to monitor...ideally on a coninuous basis, but we don't have that capability.
I can come over there and do spot checks basically...." "It appears
that the...concentration, or the level of the...styrene contaminants will vary
...depending on where I'm standing and taking my monitor reading, and also varies
based on the weather conditions to a large extent as well as the time of day that
I show up possibly...because their work level may vary...it's
unfortunate that the gym is right next to a fiberglass manufacturing company,
and I still think if they put fans...in the entry way that might help...but I
can't tell them how to run a business there..." From
Dirk, Wednesday July 25, 2007: "I did stop by...the gym area and
the parking lot, and at Peterson Products there this morning at about 7:15,...
did some readings, and...basically not a lot different than what I have been getting,
so we're... still talking parts per billion range in terms of the concentraion
of the... contaminants there, the styrene vapors ...so outside in the driveway
area along Karen Road,... about around
150, 160 ppb was the highest reading I got.
It's definitely ...more concentrated as you get closer to the corner of the gym,
gymnastics building by the roll-up door, ...but mostly...as it goes
down that driveway towards Elmer street that would be the kind of the corridor
there...between...the 2 buildings there where it's most concentrated...didn't
get a lot ...in that side parking lot...directly adjacent to the roll-up door...those
levels weren't too bad...but yeah closer to the driveway...up and down Karen Rd,
that's where it seems to be highest, again closer to the gymnastics building more
so than closer to Old County Rd. ...There
is the possibility that when they have the roll-up door up that that might
change the wind current or flow, maybe it's...creating... a negative pressure...pressure
differential when the roll-up door is open, so it might be drawing
in ..more vapors when the door is up there, possibly, since that seems to be an
area where the vapors are a little more concentrated, it's fairly close to the
...stack, vent stack coming out of Peterson Products... ...I did
go inside Peterson Products...They got some high levels in the production area
where the guys, the workers are wearing respirators...definitely
levels above the permissible exposure limit in the work area of the production
shop..."
What
is the limit provided by the ATSDR and CDC-INFO for children?
...the MRL Standard
...it
is not OSHA's 8-hour work exposure limit!!
When
considering how well the experimental data can be applied to the general population,
an uncertainty factor for human variability is used in developing the minimum
risk levels (MRL). This uncertainty factor addresses the application
of the MRL to sensitive populations, including children and the elderly, which
may not have been involved in the study population on which the MRL is based.
Therefore theMRLs
are considered protective of these sensitive populations.
source CDC-INFO,
ATSDR
The MRL for styrene = 260 micrograms
per cubic meter, which translates to ~60
ppb (at 25 °C/77 °F 1 ppm = 4.26 mg/m3, MRL translates
to 61 ppb then) source ATSDR,
EPA/TTN
Other
names for styrene (Wikipedia)
Vinyl benzene, cinnamene styrol ethenylbenzene phenethylene phenylethene diarex
HF 77 styrolene styropol
Related
information:
There are
environmental standards set for many chemicals. These standards assume exposure
24 hours per day, 7 days per week, for varying numbers of years. Most of these
environmental standards are set only for one environmental medium (ie. air, water,
soil), and dont take other pathways into account. Most
also are set for adults, not children. The Hazardous Ambient Air Standard
for styrene is 512 micrograms (µg)/m3 [~120ppb].
There are concerns about whether that
standard is adequate. If there are concerns about a specific facility,
we would suggest that you contact your local air pollution control district. -NRDCinfo
senior scientists, Gina Solomon
The
chronic inhalation REL from Cal/EPA OEHHA for styrene is 200 ppb source:
OEHHA
Texas
Short-Term Screening Level = 91.8 ppb According
to the Texas Natural Resource Conservation Commission, no health effects are thought
to occur below this level. "Short-term" levels refer to the average
exposure level during one hour. Texas Long-Term Screening Level =
9.18 According to the Texas
Natural Resource Conservation Commission, no health effects are thought to occur
below this level. "Long-term" levels refer to the average exposure level
during a year (24 hours for benzene and ethylne dichloride) ATSDR
Chronic Minimal Risk Level = 59.9 ppb According
to hte America Toxic Substances and Disease Regsitry, there is no appreciable
risk of non-cancer health effects from being exposed to concentrations up to this
level over periods longer than one year. source: Global
Community Monitor (gcm)
What
does it mean if you are smelling the styrene odor?
It
is important to note that, just because you can't smell it, it doesn't mean that
it's not there - what does it mean if you
are smelling the styrene odor? According to EPA / TTN, the odor threshold (the
lowest concentration point at which you can smell it) for styrene is 0.32 parts
per million (ppm), 320 ppb - that is over 5 times greater than the 60 ppb standard
for kids (source EPA/TTN).
Just
because you can't smell it, it doesn't mean that it's not there. But when you
do smell the styrene odor...
CALL
BAAQMD 24 hour toll-free complaint hotline
1-800-334-ODOR(6367)
"Its
odor is sweet at very low concentrations, but becomes sharp and disagreeable at
higher concentrations" (source dhs).
What
happens to styrene when it enters the environment?
Styrene
enters the environment during the manufacture, use, and disposal of styrene-based
products. It can be found in air, water, and soil.
It
is broken down in the air usually within 1 to 2 days.
It
evaporates from shallow soils and surface water.
It
doesn't stick easily to soils and sediments.
It's
broken down by bacteria in the soil and water.
It's
not expected to build up in animals.
Styrene
breaks down to half the amount within a few days in surface water; in groundwater,
however, it takes between 6 weeks and 7.5 months. source
ATSDR
More
Factory Photos and Hazard Signs
"Styrene
is primarily a synthetic chemical that is used extensively in the manufacture
of plastics, rubber, and resins..." such as the white globe in the photo
to the left. source: OSHA
NFPA
704 Standard: The sign is diamond-shaped with four smaller diamonds inside,
blue, red, yellow, andwhite. A material is assigned a rating in three categories:
health (blue), fire (red), and instability(yellow). The white box is reserved
for special hazards such as water reactivity or an oxidizer.
"NO
SMOKING OR OPEN FLAMES PERMITTED WITHIN 50 FT."
HEALTH
BLUE: Rating = 2 Hazardous Exposure
may cause temporary incapacitation or residual injury. FIRE
RED: Rating = 4 Highly flammable liquids and gases. Flash point
< 73° F. Readily capable of detonation or reaction at normal temperatures. INSTABILITY
YELLOW: Rating = 2 May undergo violent chemical change
at elevated temperatures. NFPA
source ,source: Emergency
Planning for Chemical Spills
Sample
hazard signs: Peterson Products hazard sign
worse than all of these...